Religious Inventions

Ancient Mediterranean Practice and the Study of Religion

An invitation to think differently about religion in the ancient world.

Sous la direction de William Arnal et Erin Vearncombe
438 pages, 6 x 9 pouces, 7 photos, 16 tables
Livre cartonné : 9780228024453, Mai 2025
Livre de poche : 9780228024460, Mai 2025
Livre numérique (PDF) : 9780228024477, Mai 2025
Livre numérique (EPUB) : 9780228024484, Mai 2025

Table des matières

Table des matières

Figures and Tables xi
1 Religious Inventions: Introduction 3
William Arnal and Erin K. Vearncombe
Section one: Religion as a Category of Study
2 Inventing Religion in Elephantine: Judeans and Egyptians under Persian Hegemony 21
Christine Mitchell
3 Second-Century Constructions of Christianity 36
John S. Kloppenborg
4 Theorizing Historical Moments of Religion: aul and His Followers 69
Stanley Stowers
5 Response: Religion as a Category of Study 88
Willi Braun
Section two: Undoing Text
6 Monsters, Hybridity, and Text: A Cautionary Tale 99
Heather Macumber
7 As it Was Written: The Gospel of Matthew as a Symbolic Artifact 112
Esther Guillen
8 Would You Know a Jewish Gospel if You Saw It? Ignatius, Jerome, Eusebius, and the Search for the Hebrew Gospel 130
Matthew W. Mitchell
9 Do as I Say Not as They Do: Social Construction in the Epistle of Barnabas through Canonical Interpretation and Ritual 157
Jason N. Yuh
10 Witnessing Disaster: Mark’s Gospel as a Monument to the Catastrophe of Jesus’s Death 183
Erin K. Vearncombe
11 Response: Undoing Text 199
Daniel A. Smith
Section three: Practice and Identity
12 “Hybridity,” “Identity,” and the Ancient Mediterranean World 207
Adele Reinhartz
13 Jesus, Paul, and the Geography of Magic 221
William Arnal
14 Spontaneous or Solicited? A Methodological Problem in the Study of Ancient Near Eastern Prophecy as Divination 238
Ryan D. Schroeder
15 Trauma, Meaning-Making, and Christian Identity Formation in Justin’s Dialogue with Trypho 257
Kimberly B. Stratton
16 Jubilees and Jewishness in Hasmonean Judea: Linking Text and Context in the Study of Jewish Identity with the Help of Ethnic Studies 280
John Van Maaren
17 Scripture and the Social Formation of “Displaced” Religious Communities 298
Jack N. Lightstone
18 Response: Practice and Identity 321
Alicia J. Batten
Section Four: Comparison
19 The Enchanted World of Antiquity: On Incommensurability, Religion, and Comparison 329
Heidi Wendt
20 Comparison and (Dis-)Continuity: The Case of Philo and the Alexandrian Christians 347
Jennifer Otto
21 Euergetism in Comparative Perspective: Did the “Ideal Benefactor” Exist in Christ Groups? 359
Rebecca Runesson
22 Is It Culture All the Way Down? 372
Colleen Shantz
23 The Universality of Spirit Possession Revisited 388
Giovanni B. Bazzana
24 Response: Comparison 403
Maia Kotrosits
Contributors 407
Index 411

Religion is a modern invention, a category used to describe and study certain kinds of human behaviour. Yet when it comes to the ancient world and its texts – including those that comprise the Jewish and Christian Bibles – it can be easy to forget that they did not fall from the sky as simple expressions of dogma. Rather, the ancient writings of early Judaism and Christianity are firmly rooted in the world and are the product of an astonishing array of human experience and agency: acts of self-fashioning; of imaginative speculation; of mourning and memorializing; of forming, dissolving, or refashioning group identities; and more.
Religious Inventions asks how modern conceptions of religion can shed light on the relics, textual and otherwise, of ancient Mediterranean Jews and Christians. What insights from the contemporary study of religious behaviours and practices challenge what we think we know about the ancient world? Conversely, how can thinking about the ancient world challenge what we think we know about religion today? This volume responds to these questions through explorations of the material and social circumstances behind the production of written artifacts. It examines how religious practices relate to conceptions of identity and critiques the utility of the comparative method for approaching ancient writings.
Textual authority is used and abused by many of today’s public figures. Religious Inventions offers an alternative approach to understanding how authority is constructed: from the ground up, by the creative actions and choices of real people who lived long ago.

"A bracingly original and iconoclastic exploration of how the defeat of mass revolts across the Middle East has been capitalised upon by a protean culture of the right steeped in the machinations of myth. As the Great Civil War that has traversed the region intensifies in the shadow of genocide and imperialism, States Without People is an indispensable compass. A theory for dark times." Alberto Toscano, author of Late Fascism: Race, Capitalism and the Politics of Crisis